North Carolina Court of Appeals Expands on Insurer’s Duty to Defend and Consequences of Inadequate Claims Investigation
In its October 21, 2026 decision in Eagles v. Discovery Insurance Co., COA25-610, the North Carolina Court of Appeals provided important guidance concerning an insurer’s duty to defend, the effect of actual notice of litigation, claims-handling practices, and the availability of damages and attorney’s fees when an insurer fails to provide a defense.
The dispute arose from a 2020 automobile accident involving Ikeem Cherry, who was driving a vehicle insured by Melanie Sauls. The policy extended insured status to persons using the covered vehicle but excluded an insured who used the vehicle without a reasonable belief that the person was entitled to do so. After the accident, Sauls told Discovery Insurance Company that Cherry had stolen the vehicle. A claims adjuster responded that Discovery Insurance Company would not pay anything on Cherry’s behalf because the vehicle was allegedly stolen. Significantly, the Court noted that the insurer did not further investigate that allegation or obtain the vehicle-theft affidavit required by its own claims manual.
The injured passenger later sued Cherry and Sauls. Although Cherry did not personally provide Discovery Insurance Company with suit papers, the insurer received the complaint from other sources and knew that Cherry had been sued. Cherry failed to respond, and a $3 million default judgment was entered against him. A receiver was subsequently appointed and pursued claims against Discovery Insurance Company for breach of the duty to defend, unfair and deceptive trade practices, and bad-faith failure to defend.
Actual Notice May Be Enough
The majority rejected the insurer’s contention that its duty to defend could be triggered only if Cherry personally forwarded the summons and complaint. Relying on North Carolina’s notice jurisprudence, the Court emphasized that the purpose of notice is to preserve the insurer’s ability to investigate and defend. Because Discovery Insurance Company actually received the complaint and admittedly knew that both Sauls and Cherry had been sued, the Court concluded its notice argument failed.
Equally important, the underlying complaint alleged that Cherry frequently drove the vehicle with permission and had lawful possession at the time of the accident. Those allegations, if true, potentially placed him within the policy’s coverage. Under North Carolina’s familiar comparison test that was sufficient to implicate the insurer’s defense obligations.
The decision also reinforces that an insurer may waive a notice defense by denying liability on another ground. The adjuster’s statement that the insurer would “not pay anything” because the vehicle was allegedly stolen supported the conclusion that the insurer had rejected liability independently of any purported notice deficiency.
Claims Investigation Matters
Perhaps the most significant practical lesson concerns claims handling. The Court relied on evidence that Discovery Insurance Company did not investigate the alleged theft consistent with its own claims manual and did not determine whether Cherry qualified for coverage despite knowing that he had been sued. That evidence supported summary judgment not merely for breach of the contractual duty to defend, but also for bad-faith failure to defend and unfair and deceptive trade practices.
The ruling therefore underscores the risk of making a preliminary coverage conclusion before investigating facts that may bring a claimant or putative insured within coverage.
A Significant Limitation on Damages
The decision was not a complete victory for the receiver. Before summary judgment, Discovery Insurance Company paid $1.5 million to settle with the injured passenger, and the $3 million default judgment against Cherry was marked satisfied. Because Cherry had not personally paid defense costs, settlement amounts, or demonstrated another compensable loss, the Court affirmed an award of only $10 in nominal damages. There consequently were no compensatory damages to treble under Chapter 75 and no basis for punitive damages.
Nevertheless, the Court affirmed a substantial attorney fee award under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 75-16.1, including fees associated with closely related consolidated litigation.
Takeaway
Eagles is an important reminder that North Carolina insurers should treat actual knowledge of litigation involving a potential insured as a serious defense trigger, investigate facts bearing on coverage before reaching definitive conclusions, and avoid assuming that technical deficiencies in notice will necessarily eliminate defense obligations. At the same time, the decision confirms that even where an insurer’s conduct supports breach-of-contract, bad-faith, and Chapter 75 liability, the insured must still establish an actual compensable injury to recover more than nominal damages.
One caution: Judge Tyson dissented from the majority’s duty-to-defend analysis, concluding that disputed issues concerning actual notice, compliance with the policy, good faith, and prejudice should have precluded summary judgment. This dissent will be important to watch if the case receives further appellate review.







